i loved this book! i think that yeh maybe alot of the ideas are a bit LOTR but yeh its still cool, it reminds me a bit of some kind of computer game and its fun and exciting especially when you read the second book as well.

I think gamers will enjoy this book the most. that or warhammer players... those urgals are so like beastmen!

if you found this book was a 1 or a 2 rating i recommend you read the second book because it explains alot more and changes alot of things you might have thought about the first book (ie arya's age)