This book had so much buzz and I spent the greater part of a year trying to get it at 2 libraries. Well, after finally sitting down the book, I spent 2 days of enjoyable reading. Then came the last chapter and I was MOST disappointed and even confused. Why would the author leave his story without closure? Are the readers to make up their own conclusion? I was angry and told a host of friends that are dog lovers not to read it. I will not look for this author again. I am happy to see other negative reviews; that helps a bit!