The book demanded the reader to have an open mind. It appeared to have two themes - murder and old age trials. This reader couldn't justify the continuous murder of people the main character didn't like. I know we sometimes might think we might kill someone because of irritating situation but we don't follow through or should we. Actually that phrase about killing is so inappropriate when we should offer grace instead of murder.

The trials the main character experienced with getting older certainly sound familiar and author justified. If this reader concentrated on that then the book was readable.

I wasn't sure about what this book was about. Was it about moving to a new location and finding it difficult to make friends? I found the answer. It was about making new friends and much, much more. The author drew this reader into the situations that were a bit surprising yet enlightening. I found myself "cheering on" several of the friends. Yes, I would recommend this book. I think the reader would find the book engaging from start to finish.

This book kept this reader riveted to reading the next page. Characters were believable, well-developed and likeable. One wanted both Mason and Julia to eventually become friends and allies. This was a "who-done-it" that kept the reader wondering about who was actually responsible for the many deaths/killings. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes a great mystery. My book club would love reading this one for sure.

Reading this book, reminded me of race relations in the 1920's and role women played. Women were capable, often overlooked, under-appreciated as shown in this story of Jesse and her work/dedication to W. E. B. DuBois. In Jesse's case she wanted love and a career while both were out of her reach it seemed. The author did a great job of bringing main characters to life. I would recommend this book to everyone and especially book clubs. The book would encourage some lively conversation. I enjoyed reading it. I learned about people that made a difference in promoting racial equality. Great read, in my opinion.

What a great book! The author's descriptions of The Waters location and nearby village "Whiteheart" were so good you could almost picture yourself there - visiting Rose Cottage and Boneset Table. The complex family dynamics were powerful yet it was apparent all three daughters and granddaughter were loved by the elder Hermine "Herself" Zook, the local herbalist. A variety of themes were played out in the book - value of natural remedies, effects of pollution on the environment as well as incest and rape. Book clubs would have a lot to discuss with this book.

The author has created a book with interrelated chapters involving two main characters (Henri and Louise) with different chronological reverences - dates, personal issues and settings. It involves a monetary crime committed by Louise and Henri trying to get the money returned to the rightful owners. As the story progresses both characters learn a lot about each other as well as engage in personal self reflections. The reader needs to be ready to read each chapter and keep track of each character's involvement in solving the crime. The reader will have to decide whether Louise is justified in committing the crime and if Henri is really responsible for retribution.

The Montevideo Brief would not be one I would recommend for my book club which consists of ladies interested in current issues. To be fair to the author, descriptions of various adventures of Thomas Grey were colorful and held this reader's attention. Readers who are into history involving pirates and British acquiring treasure ships from other countries would probably like this book.