i jus got down reading the book last night and i loved it!!!! obviously Paolini tries to lead us in one way and then out of no where the reallly truth comes out and it turnes out we r all wrong i think he tricked us all to believing that Eragon and Murtagh r half brothers but i think so to but i still think that he wants to lead us down that path so he can full us he is very smart no better yet A GENIUS!!!! well if u think i am wrong tlk to me! lata BYE!